Where to aim with lag
The new Reflex netcode uses a combination of extrapolation and backwards reconciliation in attempt to keep what you're seeing consistent across clients and servers. This lag compensation has an upper limit of 80ms -- if you have more than an 80ms ping, you'll need to lead by ping - 80ms. I.e, if your ping is 100ms, you'll need to lead by 20ms. Our backwards reconciliation has the same limit -- if your enemy has a ping of over 80ms, they won't be able to shoot you from 500ms in the past.
How the Reflex netcode works
Time(0): player shoots locally
Time(1): client sends packet to server saying he shot
Time(2): server receives packet saying player shot
Time(3): server steps player forward, including creating any projectiles player fired. The projectiles are fired at the time the player moved which is behind the current server time.
Time(4): gamestate is sent from server -> client
Time(5): client receives gamestate with new projectile in it. Projectile is displayed at the scene time.
1. player is half-ping behind server (in best case) in time 3. So here your rocket will be swept forward by half ping on next server step
2. in time 5, rocket is actually extrapolated ahead so it's perfectly in sync with rest of scene
3. the 80ms cap will on scene extrapolation will cause more complicated issue here, but the cap is for the greater good :)
So ultimately, rockets will look to come out further in front of you. I believe quake doesn't do the extrapolation as hard as us, which is the cause, but I could be wrong, i'm more familiar with reflex code.
A more technical explanation
We both extrapolate & BR by half ping.
Explanation: (halfping is clients half ping)
time N 1a. server has a position for all players 1b. server sends position of all players to clients in gamestate update
time N + halfping 2a. server steps time forward to time N + halfping, and records new players positions 2b. client receives gamestate informing it where players were at time N 2c. client draws frame at time N + halfping (this is extrapolating time N -> time N + halfping) 2d. client presses fire. 2e. client sends fire event in packet.
time N + halfping * 2 3a. server receives clients fire event for time time N + halfping 3b. server rewinds time to KNOWN state (time N + halfping) which it did in 2a. 3c. server applies fire that client provided in 2e. 3d. server restores players positions to time time N + halfping*2.
This stuff is quite hard to explain, let alone online in text :) But as you can see:
- the extrapolation is done in 2c, by HALF ping, on the clients screen. (i.e. it's extrapolating time N -> time N + halfping)
- the backwards reconciliation done in 3b, to put the player at the right time for when the player did the fire. (i.e. it's rewinding from time N + halfping*2 -> time N + halfping)
Yes it's curious to note that you could either extrapolate twice as much to avoid the need for BR, or BR twice as far to remove the need for extrapolation. However that would double the error in extrapolation or double the time for "getting shot around a corner" (the known BR downside).
It's also important to notice that the BR state is 100% correct as it's server authored, yet the client extrapolation state is not necessarily correct (as it's extrapolated), but we're had good results thus far :)